Rules of the Game: CODEX Rules!

July 3rd, 2005

CODEX On-Site Report

Rules of the Game: CODEX Rules! CODEX Say “Countries May Not Look Out for Their Own interests: it undermines CODEX Credibility!”

Rima E. Laibow, MD
Rome, July 3, 2005

It is hot in Rome and General Stubblebine have now been awake for about 40 hours straight. So it was annoying, but hardly surprising, that I found it almost excruciating to keep my eyes open and my mind focused on the dry, niggling items which the US Delegation pre-CODEX meeting ground slowly over. You know how it feels when you know that you have to be sharp and your mind feels like a bowl of overcooked pasta. But I snapped out of my semolina snooze when I heard that a document to which the US Delegation was committed was being passed around when Dr. Ed Scarbrough, the US CODEX Manager, noted that this document had been agreed to at the CODEX ALIMENTARIUS Commission pre meeting at which agenda items were adopted. Hence, this document represents part of the US’s CODEX Policy. Here it is, in full (with my emphasis added):

Rules Based Decision Making

It is critical for the integrity of CODEX that we abide by the rules and procedures we have set for ourselves.

CODEX’s primary objective is the protecting of the health of consumers and ensuring fair practices in the food trade and not stopping existing trade.

To do this we must rely on sound science and objective criteria in the establishment of standards.

No member or group of members should be allowed to block the work of CODEX or the acceptance of science-based standards solely de to political/economic considerations.

If we allow this to happen, we undercut the credibility that we have worked so long and hard to establish. It is this credibility as a science based organization that led the membership of the WTO to give CODEX its special status in the realm of global trade.

Two concrete examples are before the CAC this week. First is the consideration of the CMMP proposal to begin new work in the elaboration of a new standard for Parmesan Cheese.

International trade in parmesan cheese exceeds all the criteria agreed upon by the CMMP for the elaboration of individual cheeses standards.

Parmesan cheese also meets all the criteria for new worked applicable to commodities as defined in the CODRX procedural Manual. FAO and WHO legal counsel agree that geographic indicators should not restrict CODEX decision making.

Decisions made by CODEX should follow the rules and procedures established by CODEX. In the case of parmesan cheese, these criteria clearly have been met.

Unfortunately, some CODEX members have tried to block the elaboration of this standard.

Instead, they would try to introduce new principles related to intellectual property right into the CODEX decision making process. Such considerations are not appropriate for an independent, science-based and rules-based standards organization.

Similar thinking has blocked the inclusion of a particular species of sardines in the sardine standards, despite overwhelming evidence that it should be considered as an analogous species that fits well within the existing standard.

It is unacceptable to allow the political motivations of a subset of CODEX members to block the elaboration of the standards which meet the criteria established by CODEX members.

Rather, we need to follow the rules and procedures we ourselves have established.
Otherwise, we will undercut the high level of credibility that we have earned over the years.

End

What does that all mean?
Problem 1: It means that CODEX ALIMENTARIUS is beginning throw its considerable weight around to force nations to abandon what is good for them because although what is good for CODEX may NOT good for a nation and “It is unacceptable to allow the political motivations of a subset of CODEX members to block the elaboration of the standards which meet the criteria established by CODEX members.” Unacceptable to whom?

CODEX is telling WTO member nations that is it bad form for nations to protect themselves, their industries and their own health, political and economic well being lest “we undercut the credibility that we have worked so long and hard to establish….” Oh, I get it: CODEX’s credibility is more important than jobs, industries, cultural integrity and income of people. What is wrong with this dangerous picture?

From where I sit, looking out for their own political, economic and domestic good is exactly what nations are supposed to do. If you take that away from countries, you take away their sovereign rights to govern and regulate themselves. Now why would CODEX want to forbid that? See “Who is Behind CODEX” at www.HealthFreedomUSA.org for a clear picture of why, and by whom, nation states are being urged to give up their ability to manage and protect themselves lest it undermine the credibility of CODEX [sic].

Problem 2. You will also note that early on the document states, “CODEX’s primary objective is the protecting of the health of consumers and ensuring fair practices in the food trade and not stopping existing trade.”

Note that the second paragraph says, “CODEX’s primary objective is the Protecting of the health of consumers and ensuring fair practices in the food trade and not stopping existing trade.” But reading through the document, CODEX’s mission is clearly stated by saying, “No member or group of members should be allowed to block the work of CODEX or the acceptance of science-based standards solely de to political/economic considerations.

If we allow this to happen, we undercut the credibility that we have worked so long and hard to establish. It is this credibility as a science based organization that led the membership of the WTO to give CODEX its special status in the realm of global trade.”

So we are not talking about consumer protection or health enhancement, we are talking about trade regulatory power through the muscle of the World Trade Organization (WTO) regardless of whether the involved countries agree that it will be acceptable to them. If a World Government body were making this declaration, it could sound no more universally compelling or self righteous than this document to which the US CODEX Manager has committed the US.

The document also makes it clear that new concepts and intellectual property rights which might arise in international or domestic trade basis (or a domestic one, for that matter) have no place in CODEX. Circumstances are not permitted to alter cases in CODEX Land.

Problem 4. Oh, yes, one other thing: the premise of the entire document (and CODEX itself) is that CODEX is based on science and so is irrefutable. Well, it is based on science, all right: JUNK SCIENCE (commonly knows by some as tobacco science. Risk Assessment science works well for toxins but had to be retooled to fit nutrients even slightly.

Risk Assessment work fine for toxins: As far as nutrients go, it has no place in their evaluation. So if the whole CODEX deal is that it must go forward because it is science feeling See Risk Assessment and Nutrients, A Toxic Brew on www.HealthFreedomUSA.org for more information.

Tomorrow we can expect the Vitamin and Mineral Guideline (which is based on this junk science and nothing else) to come up for ratification. Rest assured that I will let you know what happens because I will be there.

Remember, the Natural Solutions Foundation brings you up to the minute news from the 28th CODEX ALIMENTARIS Commission meeting via

1. our Daily CODEX Update blog

2. Live broadcast July 6 and 13 on our internet radio show, FREE U.S./FREE US! 7-8 PM Eastern at www.FICAA.org.

And remember, Congressional support is building. Please visit www.HealthFreedomUSA.org/action and take the 6 easy steps (which include two urgently important letters to Congress urging them to follow US laws to keep America CODEX –FREE!

Yours in health and freedom,

Dr. Laibow
Natural Solutions Foundation

The Deadly CODEX Vitamin and Mineral Guideline

July 2nd, 2005

John Vidal and Tim Radford just published an article in the Guardian (UK) noting that one country in 6 is facing world food shortages this year because of severe drought following climate change (you know, the global warming that the Bush Administration changed the data to disappear it — THAT global warming) and that, since it is the climate that is growing warmer and drier, those are likely to become “semi-permanent” droughts.

They note that the worst hit are “Ethiopia, Zimbabwe, Malawi, Eritrea and Zambia, a group of countries where at least 15 million people will go hungry without aid. The situation in Niger, Djibouti and Sudan is reported to be deteriorating rapidly” according to the Food and Agriculture Organization and the US government. Then they note, “Severe droughts have also badly affected crops in Cuba, Cambodia, Australia, Afghanistan, Vietnam, Morocco, Guatemala, Honduras and Nicaragua. According to the UN’s famine early warning system, 16 countries, including Peru, Ecuador and Lesotho, face ‘unfavourable prospects’ with current crops.

In Europe, one of the worst droughts on record has hit Spain and Portugal and halved some crop yields. Both countries have applied to the EU for food assistance. In Morocco the same regional drought has devastated farming and the government fears an influx of people into the cities.

How is that connected to Health Freedom, you might ask? Very simple: under pre Vitamin and Mineral Guideline rules when a famine hit, which the UN Famine Early Warning System Director, Henri Josserand, says we are heading toward, the developed nations of the world would send food and nutrients to feed the famine victims. The afflicted countries would provide nutrient dense bars, powders, mea, biscuits or other items designed to deliver enough food to sustain the starving in a small volume, high nutrient-value delivery system.

Next week, the 28th meeting of the CODEX ALIMENTARIUS Commission is set to ratify the restrictive and, in situations like the one above, absolutely deadly, Vitamin and Mineral Guideline.

Deadly? How can a Guideline kill people?

Here’s how: CODEX standards, guidelines and regulations govern first international trade and then, through a complex mechanism (complex mechanism) domestic laws in counties like ours that have the resources to create our own standards. But countries like the ones named above which do not have those resources are urged to adopt CODEX standards as their domestic law.

So let’s look forward in time a little to the drought-ridden, starving lands of Africa or Central America. These countries have adopted the Vitamin and Mineral Guideline, which makes nutritional density illegal above that determined by Risk Assessment, a discipline of toxicology, to have zero effect on any human being.

(Risk Assessment, by the way, is good for assessing toxins, but it is not the proper science to assess nutrients with – simply because nutrients are not toxins.)

So if the countries experiencing starvation want to provide the nutrient dense nutritional support that keeps their people alive in disaster conditions, that would be against their own laws. Where would they get the nutrients from, by the way, since any company making or marketing those nutrients would have either been shut down or would have converted to making sawdust and sand nutrients: no active principal worth taking, but filler to make up the volume of the tablet or capsule?

Ok, they say, we don’t have the nutrient dense bread or bars or flour or biscuits here in our starving, drought-ridden country, but the developed nations do. Let’s go ask them. Well, the developed nations, for example the US, always like to help out when people are starving and we can feel good about feeding them so we say, “Sure, we’ll send cargo ships or planes or whatever full of nutrient-dense foods to your country.”

Oops! Not so fast!

Remember, this is post Vitamin and Mineral Standard Earth and the international shipment of those items is forbidden. Not only that, but once they got to starving wherever, they would be contraband product, illegal material because, you remember, I am sure, that material which contains anything above the nutrient density chosen by the Risk Assessment people to be unable to produce any discernable effect in the human body is forbidden. Forbidden. Think about that: anything which carries meaningful nutrition is forbidden under the Vitamin and Mineral Guideline. What is it a guideline to?

So now we have one country in 6 facing devastating drought and, if it is ratified next week in Rome, the likely prospect of vast numbers of those people starving to death in horrible suffering brought about by CODEX ALIMENTARIUS’ insane Vitamin and Mineral Standard.

Who lives? Who dies? Who decides? Do you really think that the sponsors of CODEX will not have their own sources of clean, unadulterated food and nutritional supplements? How about the starving children in ____________ (fill in the blank).

So the predictions of the two agencies responsible for creating CODEX at the behest of the UN, the World Health Organization and the Food and Agriculture Organization, that implementation of JUST the Vitamin and Mineral Guideline ALONE will result in a minimum of 3 billion deaths begins to make a little more sense. The papers and reports of these UN-organizations predict at least one billion people dying through starvation and at least two billion more through the chronic degenerative diseases of under-nutrition legislated by the Vitamin and Mineral Standard.

And your US government has chosen to support this heinous policy for ratification. We believe this is an illegal position, to say nothing of an immoral one, and have entered a Citizen’s Petition to compel them to abandon this insanity.

I will be in Rome next week along with General Stubblebine to observe the US CODEX meeting and will be reporting to you daily on the process and progress.

We have created a special web page for the Rome trip, with links to radio and blog, which you can visit here.

I cannot urge you strongly enough to take action NOW on CODEX ALIMENTARIUS. If the deadly Vitamin and Mineral Guideline is passed, the US Congress will need your pressure and support to undo it: Guidelines and Standards CAN be reopened “if there is scientific basis for doing so”. There certainly is such a basis: it is called Nutritional Science, a branch of Biochemistry.

We need your support to help Congress buck this money-tide of death and suffering, and the way to do something is to take action via the 6 easy steps.

And, oh by the way, if you imagine that the effects of this restriction will spare America, (already under-nourished and over-fed, with a weak collective immune system and dying from drugs and the chronic degenerative diseases they are meant to, but fail to, treat) think again.

When all of your food is adulterated with hormones, antibiotics and veterinary drugs and the residue levels are incredibly high and your food contains DNA from things humans have never eaten before as part of that food (or never eaten before at all) and nuked in a reactor, what do you think your health status will be like? You won’t have nutrient-dense supplements, either. So drought or no drought, we are all on the same earthship.

The CODEX Vitamin and Mineral Guideline is a planet-wide disaster.

The Natural Solutions Foundation is shaping a health defense program for you. Help us to help you by telling everyone you know about this problem and sending them to our action page so they can take action, too. (take action)

And, oh, by the way, please make as generous a donation as you can to support health and health freedom. We are working for you. Consider a monthly pledge. We appreciate it.

Make sure to tune in to our Internet radio show, FREE U.S./FREE US, live from Rome, 7-8 Eastern on www.FICAA.org. July 6 and 13.

The Vitamin and Mineral Guideline may or may not be a “happening thing” but the Natural Solutions Foundation will be in Rome to tell you what is going on.

Yours in Health and Freedom,

Rima E. Laibow, MD
Medical Director
Natural Solutions Foundation

P.S. You can support the trip to Rome with a donation.

Over One Thousand Letters Sent to Congress! More Needed…

June 29th, 2005

The latest campaign at HealthFreedomUSA consists of a letter urging Congressmen and Congresswomen to take action on the illegal pro-CODEX policy of the U.S. CODEX Office. People can send this letter via this link.

And boy, have people sent the letter!

The response has been astounding. In just one week, we have over 1000 letters sent from our web site by Americans concerned about CODEX ALIMENTARIUS, to Congressmen and Congresswomen across the country. At the time of writing, our activism software shows that 1167 letters have been sent.

This is wonderful! We at the Natural Solutions Foundation thank everyone who has taken action so far.

If you haven’t take action yet, simply click here and fill out the boxes, hit the send button, and you’re done. It’s very simple, yet very powerful. Your voice counts. Everytime a Congress representative reads a letter about CODEX, we all move one step closer to fortifying the wall to protect health freedom from the CODEX threat.

We must work together, you and us at the Natural Solutions Foundation, to build a fortress that cannot be breached, and if breached, we must be able to launch a massive media and legal campaign to expel the invader. We are currently laying the groundwork, and your help is crucial.

By now, because of grass-roots action taken via HealthFreedomUSA.org and other health freedom web sites, there is probably not one member of Congress who does not know about the CODEX ALIMENTARIUS threat to health freedom.

And most Congress representatives are hopefully by now aware that CODEX as “consumer protection” is a blatant fabrication by those who stand to profit from CODEX . CODEX serves the interests of certain industries, and it is time that this fact was known by as many Americans as possible.

Our web site shows that people will act when given the facts and when inspired to take action where there is hope that their action will make a difference.

Is there something else you can do, if you’ve already sent that letter to Congress? Yes, there are two things you can do right now:

1. Spread the word – tell at least 10 people today about HealthFreedomUSA.org. Don’t worry about what to say (I know CODEX can be tough to explain). Instead of trying to explain the CODEX problem simply refer them to the web site and let it take care of the rest. That’s what the web site is for! Go to your email inbox right now, and from your address book, drop in 10 or more email addresses into the BCC line, and send the link to HealthFreedomUSA.org, asking your contacts to visit the site. It is a good idea to also ask them to take action on the 6 Easy Steps.

2. Help us continue our work to protect your health freedom. Support our work with your much needed donations.

And keep the faith strong. We at the Natural Solutions Foundation stand firm and ready for whatever is coming. And I feel confident knowing that many of you reading this are with us, by our side in spirit.

Yours in Health and Freedom,

Rima E. Laibow, MD
Medical Director
Natural Solutions Foundation (sponsor of HealthFreedomUSA.org)

P.S. We will be in Rome next week as observers of the CODEX ALIMENTARIUS Commission meeting. Italy, here we come! We will be broadcasting radio, live from location, as well as writing frequent blog updates. Stay tuned for more information. Make sure you are subscribed to our mailing list for updates in your inbox.

A Possible Silver Lining in the Dark CODEX Cloud

June 23rd, 2005

Every cloud has a silver lining. We in the health freedom movement might just have been blessed with one.

China, Australia and Venezuela want to make itty, bitty changes to the Vitamin and Mineral Guideline (VMG) before it is ratified next July. Not that they mind it being ratified, you understand. They still want the VMG to be ratified. But, according to the Food Navigator, each of the three countries wants to introduce minor changes (a single word in one case) and this may be our silver lining!

Here’s how it could work: the CODEX Committee on Nutrition and Food for Special Dietary Uses (CCNFSDU) which includes special foods like baby formula containing Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) and trans fats, is intending to do the same harm to our dietary supplements. Restricting them to ultra low doses of very few nutrients and making all others illegal globally is perfectly fine with those three countries. However, they need to make some bureaucratic changes to make the death and chronic degenerative illness they are regulating into existence a bit more precise.

Here’s where we start to see that silver lining, folks: having reached step 8 of the process, the Vitamin and Mineral Guideline (VMG) is ripe and ready for ratification (those are the CODEX University 3 R’s: ripe, ready, ratify) at the upcoming CODEX ALIMENTARIUS Commission (CAC) meeting.

But wait!

If the guideline is changed at all, so much as by a jot or a title, it may not be approved at the CODEX ALIMENTARIUS Commission meeting. It may have to go back to the CCNFSDU committee to be re-approved!

YES!

That’s our opportunity. If it is sent back to committee because of the demands of China, Australia and Venezuela, it cannot come back around for ratification for at least another year, probably two.

And what can we do with that year or more? Just think. We have already mounted a significant legal challenge in the form of our emergency Citizen’s Petition which was presented to the US CODEX Office on June 1, 2005. Three Congressmen sent a bipartisan joint Congressional Letter to the US CODEX Office in support of that Citizen’s Petition. You have joined in, too, haven’t you? No? Click here and do it right now. It’s more important than ever and I’ll explain why.

You see, the US CODEX Office has announced its illegal policy to support the VMG in Rome next month. It has been warned by the Natural Solutions Foundation that this is an illegal policy (because it would go against established U.S. law such as DSHEA) but it has adopted it anyhow. The US CODEX Office is knowingly breaking the law and encouraging its delegates to do the same by supporting the VMG in Rome!

What does Congress have to say about the fact that we are sending a delegation of people to an international meeting with instructions from the United States Government to break US law?

Well, that’s where you come in.

Every single US Senator and Representative has been notified by the Natural Solutions Foundation that the US CODEX Office is pursuing an illegal policy, that they have been notified of the illegality of the policy and that they are breaking the law by doing so. And we have urged Congressional overview on the matter. Now here’s your part: go to www.HealthFreedomUSA.org/congress-stop-codex/ and follow instructions to send a letter to your local Congress representative. And then send the action page to everyone in your email address book using the “Email to Friend” button on the page itself.

What an opportunity: there are 3 countries who support the Vitamin and Mineral Standard who are delaying the ratification process. Let’s get our Congress to help them! Let’s give the US CODEX Office a “climb down” position: “OK, we’ll stop pushing for ratification this July. We know that it is illegal. We’ll help get the measure back to committee so we can sneak it over on you next time!” That’s fine with me, Ladies and Gentlemen of the CODEX Delegation. Just watch what we can do in the time before the next ratification attempt.

But right now, you need to tell Congress that it is NOT OK for the US CODEX Office to pursue an illegal policy and that you (and we) will be watching how they safeguard our health freedom.

Don’t delay: go to www.HealthFreedomUSA.org/congress-stop-codex/ and follow instructions to send a letter to your local Congress representative. And then send the action page to everyone in your email address book using the “Email to Friend” button on the page itself.

Oh, and by the way, we will be in Rome to observe the CODEX ALIMENTARIUS Commission meeting and we need your financial support to do that: it is expensive but very important that we are there to see, and report accurately what happens.

Yours in Health and Freedom,

Rima E. Laibow, MD
Medical Director
Natural Solutions Foundation

P.S. Make sure to donate to support the work of the Natural Solutions Foundation in protecting your health freedom.

Tell Congress You Want US CODEX Policy to Match US Law!

June 20th, 2005

EMERGENCY ACTION ALERT!

On June 9, 2005 the US CODEX Manager, Dr. Edward Scarbrough announced that US Policy would defy US law. Although Title 19, USC 3512 prohibits the US from “HARMonizing” with foreign standards which violate US law, Dr. Scarbrough said that the US would support the ratification of the Vitamin and Mineral Standard at the upcoming meeting in Rome next month. Upon this declaration of illegal action, the Natural Solutions Foundation immediately appended our Citizen’s Petition to reflect US Policy. But we have done something else, too, and we need your help.

We, the People, are calling upon the people we have given jobs to, the US Congress, the hold an emergency Congressional Hearing to identify the culprits in this illegal policy decision and set US CODEX policy in accord with US law. But Congress only listens to its voting constituents. You are the key to whether this Congressional Hearing takes place. Yes, YOU! It is imperative that you send an urgent message to Congress requesting an Emergency Congressional Hearing (Emergency Congressional Hearing) to maintain the rule of law. PLEASE DO IT RIGHT NOW. And, oh, by the way, make sure that you tell everyone that you know, all over the country, to do the same thing. Remember, the CODEX meeting takes place from July 4-9 in Rome.

This really is an emergency! We need voices from all over the United States to compel Congress to act. Don’t delay. We really need every voice.

Yours in health and freedom,

Rima E. Laibow, MD
Medical Director
Natural Solutions Foundation